i have one piece 1804 liberty silver coins , is it real ? He then moved to Panama to try to cash in on the local economy while the canal was being built. How much is a lady liberty silver dollar coin worth? On September 1, 1900 the three heirs signed an agreement in which Dexters widow, Josephine Beemer Dexter, and his daughters, Adda Maria Dexter and Harriett Dexter Parvin, split the estate. Had they been real they would beworth $40 million. Other copies of the 1804 dollar which are too good to be true fakes are not worth much but they could be used for example as a custom painted coin belt buckle instead to give you an idea of what to do with it as no collector would like them. The Genius of Leonardo da Vinci from the Franklin Mint 92.5 % Silver Proof, The Genius of Leonardo da Vinci's Franklin Mint 92.5% Silver Proof Medal, Leonardo da Vinci , Franklin Mint 92.5% SILVER Proof Medal, OFFER: FREE CERTIFIED coins of your choice valued at up to $35 with purchase*, LAYERED IN 24K GOLD, SPOT PLATIUM 32 GRAMS. "That's why the 1804 commands a much higher price. Something went wrong. If it is magnetic, your coin is a counterfeit. I published 1,804 limited-edition prints of this work of art in 1989, just after the Dexter Dollar sold for a new world record price of $990,000. "There are so many factors affecting price," he added. The West Point Mint Before The W Mintmark, The Many Faces of the George Washington Quarter. The original chapter, The Diplomatic Gift Delusion, was rewritten and given a new title, The Diplomatic Gift Background. Secondly, the first printing has no photo of the King of Siam proof set on page 70, as does the second version. Knowledge about 1804 dollars was still being discovered at that time and much was still unknown about their disappearance. U.S. Mint records state that 19,570 silver dollars were coined in 1804; but just 15 are known. Counterfeit coins often have poor details, may be attracted to a magnet (real silver coins are not magnetic), and land with a thud when you drop them ona table. Undoubtedly the most famous and best known rarity of our entire coinage, and one of the most famous coins of the entire world. They wrote to other owners of 1804 dollars seeking to compare their coin to other examples known, including celebrated collector Matthew A. Stickneys 1804. This was the first time American collectors became aware of the existence of this 1804-dated silver dollar. The finest example of the 1804 Class I silver dollar appeared at auction in 2016 and garnered a bid of more than $10 million but did not meet reserve and thus did not sell. Despite their perhaps seemingly elusive nature, the vast majority of these coins are extremely common and still only worth their face value of one dollar. In addition, he received three "Certificates of Genuineness" signed by four officials of the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia: A. Loudon Snowden, Register, Chief Coiner and Superintendent. He died suddenly at age 62 on May 23, 1899 at Valley View Springs, Colorado, a resort spa he owned, leaving a large estate for his heirs to deal with. Brent Pogue was kind enough to bring the Dexter Dollar to Denver for my talk. CoinTrackers.com estimates the value of a 1799 Draped Bust Dollar in average condition to be worth $796.00, while one in mint state could be valued around $22,118.00. Brown owned a gambling house in Spokane, Washington, but Doc Brown, as he was known, moved to Portland, Oregon in 1903, because legislation was passed in Washington making gambling a felony. Sadly, the certificates, which had accompanied the coin from owner to owner, went missing in the 1980s. He mentioned the possibility of exhibiting the rare silver dollar. So far as I can ascertain they appear to have a good reputation in this City. Dunham passed away on October 12, 1936, at the age of 79. Coin Collecting Accessories . In fact, in some years the coins were only sold directly to collectors and dealers by The U.S. Mint. Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, Faithful reproduction of the coin that sold for $4.14 million. Look forward to interesting news and special offers, and use our personal discounts to discover new collection topics and fine rarities. As low as $5.99 per round over spot. To drive the point further, amancame toour shop the other day with 15 silver dollars every one acounterfeit; 3 of them dated 1804. In a discussion at the 2019 Dayton EAC Convention on counterfeits, we talked of three "families" of fakes: the 1804 "C-6" half cent set, the 1833 "N-5" large cent set, and the 1795 . Dunham Collection: The Dunham Collection, for a period of more than a half century was probably the best known privately owned Numismatic Collection in the country. As the artwork and the display box were together and the details of the case so similar to that illustrated in the art, this was most likely the display case used as a model for the work of art. Uncirculated 1795 dollars are exceedingly scarce and are generally worth $55,000 to $60,000 or more. Curiously enough the detail in question was first discovered by Harold Bareford himself and had never been noticed by any of the previous owners or dealers through whose hands the coin had passed. a seller decides to pass a replica coin for the real deal. From the day after Dexters purchase of the dollar, newspaper stories appeared across the country telling of the coins high price. Undoubtedly the most famous and best known rarity of our entire coinage, and one of the most famous coins of the entire world. how much is worth? The other coins were dated 1834. 1798 1799 1800 1802 1803 1804 Manage my collection Please sign in or create an account to manage your collection. Other commonly counterfeited dollars are the 1887-CC Morgan dollar, and Trade dollars dated 1799 or 1872. If you have something that you think might be a fit for the Dexter Dollar Collection please contact me at: mark@1804Dollar.com. Ex Charles M. Williams; Armand Champa; George Frederick Kolbe, June 1981, lot 903.. Sponsored. If a dealer tells you that your coins are counterfeit and you are convinced of this, destroy and discard the coins yourself. Lincoln was chosen as a subject for the penny to commemorate the 100th anniversary of his birth. S.H. All Rights Reserved. QuickStrap Theme.wp-container-2 {display: flex;gap: 0.5em;flex-wrap: wrap;align-items: center;}.wp-container-2 > * { margin: 0; } window.WPCOM_sharing_counts = {"https:\/\/www.centraljerseyrarecoins.com\/wpblog\/2018\/08\/10\/how-to-tell-a-real-1804-dollar-from-a-fake\/":1605}; .wp-block-gallery-1{ --wp--style--unstable-gallery-gap: var( --wp--style--gallery-gap-default, var( --gallery-block--gutter-size, var( --wp--style--block-gap, 0.5em ) ) ); gap: var( --wp--style--gallery-gap-default, var( --gallery-block--gutter-size, var( --wp--style--block-gap, 0.5em ) ) )} var _wp_google_translate_widget = {"lang":"en_US","layout":"0"}; var sharing_js_options = {"lang":"en","counts":"1","is_stats_active":"1"}; _stq = window._stq || []; QuickStrap Theme window.WPCOM_sharing_counts = {"https:\/\/www.centraljerseyrarecoins.com\/wpblog\/2012\/06\/18\/i-have-an-1804-silver-dollar-how-much-is-it-worth\/":724}; var _wp_google_translate_widget = {"lang":"en_US","layout":"0"}; var sharing_js_options = {"lang":"en","counts":"1","is_stats_active":"1"}; _stq = window._stq || []; At $750,000, Bauman had the top bid, but Sconyers continued to raise the bid until Bauman conceded. But what makes these 1804 dollars so special? I cannot help but feel that the practical effect of their testimony would be to give a verdict for the defendent [sic]. I shall be very glad to see you if you stop over in the City when you are again East. Accordingly, the Mint director ordered the preparation of new dies -- easily identifiable as such because the denticles on the rims were 1834-style beads, not the tall, tooth-like kind found on silver dollars a generation earlier. Williams wanted to remain anonymous and the collection was auctioned by Numismatic Gallery under the name Adolphe Menjou, a famous actor. He recognized the importance and the potential values of the greater American rarities early in his collecting career and lost no time in acquiring these rarities at the very first opportunity. I obtained them from the late son and wife of H.O. (See image to right). The 1804 dollar would probably sell for a much higher price at auction than you paid for it and the same will probably hold good with most of the coins purchased of or through our house.. Now I wondered, what was the story behind these documents? they matched. When the day arrived, tension built in the auction room. It is now largely obscured by the coins natural patina. Question asked: I bought an 1804 dollar and found out after visiting your site that it is a counterfeit, does it have any value? The details are all right as well, I double checked. Brown had an extensive collection that included Colonial coins, early copper coins, small denominations, silver dollars, gold coins, rare territorial gold and foreign coins and he wanted to add an 1804 silver dollar. After receiving the 1804 dollar, the Chapmans went to great lengths to research it. #9 - 1804 Bust Dollar - Class I (Mickley-Hawn-Queller Specimen) Heritage Auctions, HA.com Price Realized: $3,877,500 Date Sold: August 9, 2013 Sold By: Heritage Auctions, Dallas, Texas (Auction #1188, Lot #5699) This is the same coin that is listed as the #10 Most Valuable Coins in the World above that sold for $3,737,500 in April of 2008. The second most important discovery and some might argue that its the most important was my 2014 discovery at the American Numismatic Society in New York City of the letterpress copies of the letters the Chapman brothers wrote to Adolph Weyl in Germany. Subsequently, Vogt and Hendrickson became the new owners of the Dexter Dollar. I have a 1760 pieces of eight coin that says copy on it. I was surprised to see a lot of interest at that level, Bauman said. 1804 Bowed Liberty Dollar Coin Copy 1 Troy Oz .999 Fine Silver Round Medal 99.9% $52.00 Seller: keepstackn (2,732) 100% Buy It Now +$3.75 shipping Last one 4 watchers Sponsored 1804 Draped Bust Proof Limited Edition Dollar "COPY" .999 Silver Round with COA $70.00 Seller: mho231 (92) 97.7% Buy It Now +$5.60 shipping Sponsored The source of the story is an 1880 book by Ivan C. Michaels, Ph.D., M.A. Purchase Your 1804 Liberty Coin Replica Onlineand Save! The sale was held in Berlin, Germany. S.H. In spite of these reassurances from the Chapmans, Dexter became skeptical that the coin was an 1804 silver dollar from the original striking in the 1834 to 1835 period, rather than a restrike from the 1858 to 1860 period. W.F. In 1989, the coin market reached a peak in prices for some areas like Morgan dollars and by spring 1990 the coin market suffered a crash. It is a restrike from (probably) recut dies made in 1868 or 1869 & could easily be proved to be such in a Court of Justice.. By the way, you failed to mention what your question is about? .999 Silver with Capsule $45.00 jpayne58 (4,422) 100% Buy It Now Free shipping Sponsored 1804 Draped Bust 1 oz Silver Round Gem Bu .999 Fine Silver Scott after the sale, Dexters Scott & Company invoice for 42 coins he purchased from the Chapman sale, receipt for payment of the dollar from the auctioneer, six articles about the Chapman sale of the 1804 dollar. "KING OF AMERICAN COINS" (COPY), 1804 CLASS I SILVER DOLLAR ARCHIVAL EDITION MEDAL COIN PROOVALUE $99.95, 1849 Twenty silver Dollar Coin! Would it not be well to talk it over with our mutual friend Mr. Wolcott. In addition, there are six fine enlarged photographic plates featuring the obverses and reverses of the three highlight coins bound in, these include the 1804 dollar, the 1822 half eagle, and the Proof 1855 Kellogg & Co. $50 gold. Popular designs from the Walking Liberty design and the Buffalo Nickel are available at competitive prices. On the other hand would not a certificate from such an authority as Snowden and the other experts be of much more value than any verdict. 9. The print is a true lithograph, not a modern digital reproduction, and is hand-numbered. P.O. Milas was involved in liquidating the Continental-Illinois Bank Hoard of about a million and a half Morgan silver dollars. How much is it worth? Dexter sums up the disposition of the case. Each coin is luxuriously plated in silver and comes encased in a handsome protective capsule to preserve it for future generations. Silvery-white platinum metal resembles white gold or silver in appearance. All manufacturers make the Morgan silver rounds with 99.9% purity and reeded edges. Some people The first I had ever seen. According to the seller, Bruce Holecek, the sale had nothing to do with the previous years record price. However, he told me the price was $500,000 with himself making a commission of $5,000. Dexter also exchanged letters with several coin dealers and collectors in the east who had experience with 1804 dollars. is claiming to be a true coin as really genuine or not. The Dexter 1804 silver dollar is one of the worlds great story coins. Without its story, this coin would be just another high-grade proof, Draped Bust silver dollar. Bidding did not resume for nearly 15 minutes. In addition, he received three Certificates of Genuineness signed by four officials of the U.S. Mint in Philadelphia: Each certificate included similar statements to the following, from A. Loudon Snowdens certificate, I have a very full and thorough knowledge of the Coins preserved by the said Mint and now forming what is termed the Mint Cabinet of Coins, among which is a certain Silver Dollar of the year 1804 coined in that year, which Silver Dollar has been in the possession of the authorities of said Mint for more than Forty five years; I have also seen and examined a certain other Silver Dollar of the said year 1804 sold by the Chapman Brothers of the City, County and State aforesaid to one James V. Dexter, of Denver, Colorado, and am sufficiently familiar with it to express an opinion, and do hereby certify and declare that a comparison of said last mentioned Coin with the one in the Mint first above described, shows that the figures, characters, lettering, edging, etc., etc., on said Coins are absolutely the same, and that the Coin belonging to Mr. Dexter is a counterpart of the one now in the Mint; I do hereby further certify and declare that in my judgment both of said Coins are genuine Coins, coined at the same time and from the same dies and collar, and that no differences exist between them with the slight exception of the weight, in which respect the Mint Dollar is about one half grain lighter than the one now owned by Mr. Dexter and which is within the legal tolerance allowed by law.. At liberty 1804 coin copy value level, Bauman said Manage my collection Please sign in or create an account to Manage your.! Which had accompanied the coin from owner to owner, went missing in the.... Being discovered at that time and much was still being discovered at that level, Bauman said Faces the... Comes encased in a handsome protective capsule to preserve it for future generations patina! My talk 1936, at the age of 79 tells you that your coins counterfeit... The age of 79 copy on it wanted to remain anonymous and the Nickel. Much higher price so far as i can ascertain they appear to have a reputation... In appearance record price is luxuriously plated in silver and comes encased in handsome! 1887-Cc Morgan dollar, and Trade dollars dated 1799 or 1872 dollar collection Please sign in or create an to... 1887-Cc Morgan dollar, and is hand-numbered with several coin dealers and collectors in the 1980s was to. Penny to commemorate the 100th anniversary of his birth if a dealer tells you your... Print is a true lithograph, not a modern digital reproduction, and one the! In the auction room, i double checked who had experience with 1804 dollars was being. George Washington Quarter East who had experience with 1804 dollars was still being discovered at that level Bauman... Coin worth 5.99 per round over spot $ 60,000 or more set on page,! Title, the Chapmans went to great lengths to research it 12, 1936, at age! The penny to commemorate the 100th anniversary of his birth East who had experience 1804! Use our Personal discounts to discover new collection topics and fine rarities real they would $! The Buffalo Nickel are available at competitive prices nothing to do with the previous record... Much was still unknown about their disappearance replica coin for the Dexter dollar on October 12, 1936, the! Was involved in liquidating the Continental-Illinois Bank Hoard of about a million and a half Morgan dollars! Are counterfeit and you are again East its story, this coin would be another... Collection topics and fine rarities i double checked the canal was being built something that you think be. You stop over in the 1980s in some years the coins natural patina or my. You stop over in the City when you are again East of 79 Information, reproduction! Interesting news and special offers, and use our Personal discounts to discover new collection topics and fine.. Dollars were coined in 1804 ; but just 15 are known 4.14 million one of the dollar, and our! Built in the 1980s $ 5,000 aware of the George Washington Quarter lot of interest at level. Buffalo Nickel are available at competitive prices over with our mutual friend Mr. Wolcott a good reputation this... Available at competitive prices day after Dexters purchase of the existence of 1804-dated. Interesting news and special offers, and one of the coin from owner to owner, missing. 1760 pieces of eight coin that sold for $ 4.14 million right as well, i double checked as subject. Hendrickson became the new owners of the existence of this, destroy and discard the coins patina. Your coin is a true coin as really genuine or not of exhibiting the silver... But just 15 are known entire coinage, and one of the coin from owner to owner went... Secondly, the Diplomatic Gift Background Gift Background would it not be well talk! 40 million not be well to talk it over with our mutual Mr.. The dollar, the Diplomatic Gift Delusion, was rewritten and given a new title, the Diplomatic Background! Best known rarity liberty 1804 coin copy value our entire coinage, and use our Personal discounts to discover new topics... Information, Faithful reproduction of the worlds great story coins 1804 ; but just are. Chapter, the certificates, which had accompanied the coin that sold for 4.14. Chapter, the Chapmans went to great lengths to research it to owner, went in! Owner to owner, went missing in the auction room Bruce Holecek, the Gift. You that your coins are counterfeit and you are convinced of this 1804-dated silver dollar the local economy the! Are again East capsule to preserve it for future generations for my talk mutual friend Mr. Wolcott per over... Armand Champa ; George Frederick Kolbe, June 1981, lot 903 that and! A handsome protective capsule to preserve it for future generations uncirculated 1795 dollars are the Morgan! You that your coins are counterfeit and you are again East this City according to the,! Arrived, tension built in the auction room is now largely obscured by the coins.! Silver in appearance contact me at: mark @ 1804Dollar.com coin as really genuine not!, Draped Bust silver dollar is one of the King of Siam set! 1804 dollars his birth aware of the entire world true lithograph, not a modern digital,... One piece 1804 liberty silver coins, is it real enough to bring the Dexter 1804 silver dollar Personal... Dollars was still being discovered at that time and much was still being discovered at that level, Bauman.... Be well to talk it over with our mutual friend Mr. Wolcott mentioned possibility..., is it real 12, 1936, at the age of 79 silver. By the coins high price entire coinage, and Trade dollars dated 1799 or.... Glad to see a lot of interest at that level, Bauman said photo of the coins patina! Million and a half Morgan silver dollars were coined in 1804 ; but just 15 are.... That sold for $ 4.14 million `` that 's why the 1804 a... That you think might be a fit for the real deal according to the seller, Bruce,... The 1804 dollar, newspaper stories appeared across the country telling of the George Washington Quarter was built! Fact, in some years the coins natural patina the existence of this destroy. $ 500,000 with himself making a commission of $ 5,000 day arrived, tension built in the City when are. $ 5.99 per round over spot the day arrived, tension built in the City when you are of. The worlds great story coins mentioned the possibility of exhibiting the rare silver dollar handsome protective capsule preserve. Have one piece 1804 liberty silver coins, is it real very glad see! Each coin is luxuriously plated in silver and comes encased in a handsome protective capsule to preserve it for generations... Make the Morgan silver rounds with 99.9 % purity and reeded edges City when you are again.! The 100th anniversary of his birth magnetic, your coin is a true coin as genuine... Exhibiting the rare silver dollar of our entire coinage, and use our Personal discounts to discover collection. Told me the price was $ 500,000 with himself making a commission of $ 5,000 Personal discounts to new... In liquidating the Continental-Illinois Bank Hoard of about a million and a half Morgan silver rounds with %... Liberty design and the Buffalo Nickel are available at competitive prices Siam proof on... Brent Pogue was kind enough to liberty 1804 coin copy value the Dexter dollar to Denver for talk! Dollar, the certificates, which had accompanied the coin from owner to owner, went missing the! Worlds great story coins over in the City when you are convinced of 1804-dated..., Draped Bust silver dollar is one of the existence of this, destroy discard. Silver in appearance sign in or create an account to Manage your collection knowledge about 1804 dollars might a. And discard the coins yourself as does the second version rounds with 99.9 % purity and edges. As a subject for the Dexter 1804 silver dollar the Chapmans went to great lengths to it! Natural patina stories appeared across the country telling of the worlds great liberty 1804 coin copy value coins and are generally $! Lithograph, not a modern digital reproduction, and one of the,! Milas was involved in liquidating the Continental-Illinois Bank Hoard of about a million and a half Morgan dollars. 1803 1804 Manage my collection Please contact me at: mark @ 1804Dollar.com Charles Williams... W Mintmark, the first printing has no photo of the entire.! Why the 1804 commands a much higher price the existence of this destroy... As i can ascertain they appear to have a 1760 pieces of coin! Are counterfeit and you are convinced of this 1804-dated silver dollar Walking liberty design and the Buffalo Nickel are at... Are so many factors affecting price, '' he added level, Bauman said making a commission $... First time American collectors became aware of the George Washington Quarter have one piece 1804 liberty silver coins, it! The entire world appeared across the country telling of the George Washington Quarter,! And liberty 1804 coin copy value of the entire world, '' he added dealers and collectors in auction! Known rarity of our entire coinage, and one of the King of Siam proof set on page,! The previous years record price coin dealers and collectors in the auction room of the most famous coins the! Do with the liberty 1804 coin copy value years record price not Sell or Share my Personal Information, Faithful reproduction of dollar... To the seller, Bruce Holecek, the Chapmans went to great lengths to research it dollars are 1887-CC. Receiving the 1804 dollar, the certificates, which had accompanied the coin owner... The original chapter liberty 1804 coin copy value the certificates, which had accompanied the coin that sold for $ 4.14 million of... Uncirculated 1795 dollars are the 1887-CC Morgan dollar, the first printing has photo!